Sumo

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Dine' bashing

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Dine' bashing

    This post is in reference to comments made in the "what is with navajo's and southern style dancing" thread.

    At the Gathering back maybe 9 years ago, Blacklodge and Cozad were both present. During one of the intertribal dances, Blacklodge sang a well-known Cozad song. They performed a very impressive rendition of that song. At the conclusion of that song, the Cozad singers came over and put money on the drum, shook all the BL singers hands and gave two thumbs up. It appeared to me, that the Cozad singers were flattered and proud to have their song sung by BL. To me, this defined the essence of "Pow Wow".

    The native people here, who refer to us Dine' as copycats, damned people, snobs, and know-it-all, have given me a different view and meaning of what "Pow Wow" is becoming.

    I realize, as well as others here (Dine' and non-Dine'), that we have infringed on what they feel belongs to them. There's really not much we (individually) can do about this. These are individual choices. As was said countless times, there are Dine' who have the privilege to wear and dance non-Dine' styles, for they were gifted this practice. Albeit, there are others who have found that they can cash in on monetary prizes and awards, without haven't been given that privilege. Please suggest a way to distinguish one from the other. The only way I can distinguish this, is to simply ask that person simple questions that will satisfy my curiosity. So, what will you do if you find a Dine', Hopi, Pueblo person who didn't have this privilege? Chastise them on the internet? Call them names? How will this help you? Will it just get you friends, so that you can fuel one another's venting and flaming? For me, I wouldn't like to have friends who are like that.

    I have no authority to speak on every Dine's behalf, nor can I forbid them to practice other cultures' traditions of song and dance. For the Dine' whom I know, that dance, they are respectful perfectionists that want to experience the essence of Pow Wow that I witnessed back at the Gathering. Some have perfected their gift so much, that it is beginning to infringe on other dancers' notoriety and purses.

    513 years ago, our dances flourished and were held with a meaning behind each and everyone. Later, as the numbers of our people diminished, we held on to what little remained in the minds of those who survived. Different nations shared their rituals and songs in hope that the shear numbers of singers and dancers would help their shared goals. Why does this have to change?

    My peace and harmony enter your hearts.
    "We who are clay blended by the Master Potter, come from the kiln of Creation in many hues. How can people say one skin is colored, when each has its own coloration? What should it matter that one bowl is dark and the other pale, if each is of good design and serves its purpose well." ~~~Polingaysi Qoyawayma, Hopi~~~

  • #2
    Originally posted by vince_j
    This post is in reference to comments made in the "what is with navajo's and southern style dancing" thread.

    At the Gathering back maybe 9 years ago, Blacklodge and Cozad were both present. During one of the intertribal dances, Blacklodge sang a well-known Cozad song. They performed a very impressive rendition of that song. At the conclusion of that song, the Cozad singers came over and put money on the drum, shook all the BL singers hands and gave two thumbs up. It appeared to me, that the Cozad singers were flattered and proud to have their song sung by BL. To me, this defined the essence of "Pow Wow".

    The native people here, who refer to us Dine' as copycats, damned people, snobs, and know-it-all, have given me a different view and meaning of what "Pow Wow" is becoming.

    I realize, as well as others here (Dine' and non-Dine'), that we have infringed on what they feel belongs to them. There's really not much we (individually) can do about this. These are individual choices. As was said countless times, there are Dine' who have the privilege to wear and dance non-Dine' styles, for they were gifted this practice. Albeit, there are others who have found that they can cash in on monetary prizes and awards, without haven't been given that privilege. Please suggest a way to distinguish one from the other. The only way I can distinguish this, is to simply ask that person simple questions that will satisfy my curiosity. So, what will you do if you find a Dine', Hopi, Pueblo person who didn't have this privilege? Chastise them on the internet? Call them names? How will this help you? Will it just get you friends, so that you can fuel one another's venting and flaming? For me, I wouldn't like to have friends who are like that.

    I have no authority to speak on every Dine's behalf, nor can I forbid them to practice other cultures' traditions of song and dance. For the Dine' whom I know, that dance, they are respectful perfectionists that want to experience the essence of Pow Wow that I witnessed back at the Gathering. Some have perfected their gift so much, that it is beginning to infringe on other dancers' notoriety and purses.

    513 years ago, our dances flourished and were held with a meaning behind each and everyone. Later, as the numbers of our people diminished, we held on to what little remained in the minds of those who survived. Different nations shared their rituals and songs in hope that the shear numbers of singers and dancers would help their shared goals. Why does this have to change?

    My peace and harmony enter your hearts.


    UMMM..... Well put vince j...
    I think .. now, this is just my opinion.. i have noticed people start hollering when the infringement happens... i mean, when it is noticible. And it is noticible when the winnings take place. I think we should just let our Native brothers and sisters enjoy what they do best and that's singing and dancing. We are a very talented group of people. We have artistic talent that shows in our regelia and craftwork. We could create different songs and dance movements... non other like non-Native people.
    So, i do not understand the bashing going on. I mean, there are people out there who wish they were Native and now we have our own people degrading each other... MAN!!!
    that's my take.
    Happy Trails!....

    Comment


    • #3
      It is really a shame that someone would single out the Dineh but I for one do not harbor any ill feelings. There are two Dineh dancers who probably upped the ante for powwows during the early 90's. Those two are Darlene Beetso (jingle) and Antoinette Begay (fancy shawl).

      Comment


      • #4
        Are powwows truely "Intertribal?" Who owes it? Who is going to tell all of "us" Navajos what we can and can't do? Who is going to be the powwow police.

        Many Navajo's who powwow are well known. Are they all stuckup or snobby? I have traveled all around the country. But very rarely does someone from another tribe come up and not act stuckup or snobby. Those traits are not exclusively Navajo. I would say many Indian people are shy about meeting new people, then after you get to know them you find out they are nice and friendly.

        Honestly, out here on the rez, you rarely see or hear Navajo people making a spectacle of themselves (except maybe the younger generation). They do not want to be noticed or intrusive. Just like many other tribes.

        I have attended powwows since I was a little girl. I think powwow snobbery is rampant, but not just from the Navajos.

        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by quicksilverwade
          It is really a shame that someone would single out the Dineh but I for one do not harbor any ill feelings. There are two Dineh dancers who probably upped the ante for powwows during the early 90's. Those two are Darlene Beetso (jingle) and Antoinette Begay (fancy shawl).
          I think this is the problem....

          For some people to loose to Spike Draper, Shawn Yazzie, Tiffany Paskimin, Ursaloria Kanuho, Ursela Windy Boy, Sharon Brokeshoulder, Wanda Nelson, Nathan Largo, Candace McCabe. "It's just now fair......" (all whiney)

          Comment


          • #6
            Love 'em, Hate 'em...

            Dang, I really thought this thread was about Dine' Bashas'.

            I was wondering if mutton neck was on sale and if they bought pinon seeds. HAHAHA

            Navajo to the bone! Pun intended!

            I'll still powwow whether they like it or not!!! And you should too!!!
            There are no answers, only the search.
            Grandma Ivy

            Comment


            • #7
              quote
              Last edited by Heinz 57; 08-30-2012, 11:13 PM.

              Comment


              • #8
                I think

                I think if the people think such and such tribe should not wear or dance any other style and if that is so important...why don't they know how to speak and write their own language. I mean, if they think traditionally and believe the ways of their tribe they should know how to speak their language at least. How in the world are they going to get the direct teachings of the elders who don't know english? Just my two cents.

                And yeah, why can't everybody just get along and be proud of your American Indian heritage and the proud fact that we once owned the whole United States.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Native people that bash or put down other native people over the topic of powwows are called,"POWWOW NAZIS!" Just my 2 cents.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Waa Haa

                    Shaa Haanee, I thought it said "Dine Bashas" I was 'bout to point fingers and lips
                    "I Ahula Ula"
                    Enjoying the ride.
                    BETA SIGMA EPSILON

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by Tiyospaye Yazzie
                      Shaa Haanee, I thought it said "Dine Bashas" I was 'bout to point fingers and lips
                      Yeah, TY, point with those dry-cracked-weathered-lips-that-could-use-a-good-greasy-mutton-rib-to-heal lips to point with, eh?

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        LOL!!!! gaw bet u got all excited for strawberry bashas' pop huh? yeah i was bout to pull out my keychain with my Bashas savings card, cuz fifty cents goes a long way :p.
                        Apache jump on it, jump on it, jump on it!!!!!

                        "Insert words of wisdom here"

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Bad apples...red on the outside and white and rotten on the inside

                          It is a shame that we have "powwow nazis" (I use that word too). There are many very talented Dine' out there and have been powwow'ng since childhood and their parents before them, so I'm asking one question, "So who do we consider #1 on the Powwow list?" Is that what it means to bash other tribes and say you are infringing on our dances and regalias....naw, doesn't work that way. Last time I checked we all were humans, faced oppression, been to boarding schools, forced out of our lands, our braids cut and labeled "savages", the government wanting to "getting rid of all Indians". That goes from the East coast, Mid-west, Northern country, Southwest, West Coast, Pacific Northwest, and the Canadian tribes. So I think just because you are from a certain region of the U.S. doesn't make you a better tribe. Last time I checked, our reservations all looked alike too. We also happened to all have palettes for frybreads, LOL! I don't see the significance of bashing the Dine'? What if I started a thread and said the Oklahoma natives are stealing Dine' dances and think they should stop, because we are better? Or, the Cree shouldn't wear regalia from the Ojibway tribes? I think of all natives as equals. I don't care where you are from, we are all NATIVES.

                          Another concern of mine, most drums share songs throughout powwow country. It just doesn't make sense to me. You see all these recorders at the powwows. They are recording you words and talents, then share it with whomever and wherever in all four directions of the globe. If it's so prudent to save your songs and languages why are most drums and singers selling cd's at powwows? Think about it "powwow nazis" you have no right to tell a Dine' or another tribe what to do? How about some Dine' who are half-blooded? The maternal side teaching Dine' ways and the paternal teaching, let's say for example, Lakota. You don't have the right to tell an individual what to do? I think if certain people/tribes are defensive about their ways and dances, why take it to a powwow? Powwow is a public dance. Everytime there is a powwow we are opening ourselves to the rest of the world who can make copies of our dresses and dances and make profit off of it. Just think about it, the other race are so intrigued by our feathers, mocassins, dresses, beadwork, etc. they make replicas of them and we find fake feathers for sale at the next powwow with words like "Authentic Native American" then when you look at it, it's MADE IN CHINA. So if you think your dances and dresses should remain sacred and kept within the family, don't expose yourself to the public. The Dine' are very protective of their prayers and ceremonies. You don't see a yei'bi-chei dances going on in Cali do you? We don't sing our ceremonial chants at powwows because we believe it's a divine gift only shared among the people. Yes, there are the bad apples who record and sell them (shame on them), but majority of Dine' don't approve of other races at most sacred ceremonies and we don't go parading it around powwows. My point is, if you powwow, you have just opened yourself to free trade. Free trade to other tribes and other races. We can't change history and if you have a problem with the Dine', why don't you take up your arguement with every Dine' in powwow country and explain why you don't want that person dancing your style or singing your native songs, posting a thread on here only heats up the division and hatred for one another. It's quite sad that there is still discrimination and hatred in powwow country, in the end it'll be your own inner destruction.
                          Last edited by **jdazmum**; 10-19-2005, 01:00 AM.
                          Fall down 7 times, get up 8. MY FAMOUS WORDS.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            I think that 100% Navajos who have all four clans should stick to dressing their traditional style. That way everyone will know that you are proud of yourself and not trying to be another tribe and still dance pow-wow. I thought that Navajos are not supposed to wear eagle feathers on their heads unless you are a Hatathlie. I just think that other tribes don't like to see their clothes being worn like a costume. They do have designs that let you know what tribe they are or they wear their hair a certain way or their bustles are different from each other. It seems inconsiderate to just wear something from another tribe just because it looks pretty or because you could win some money. I myself don't like to see Southern Straight Dancers dance that are not from Oklahoma because this is directly where it comes from. I read Dine responses that are quite defensive and that's okay because we all know that they are not going to stop just because some object, but at least think about what you wear and why you are dancing your style.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Aho' swbreez, you are correct. Dine aren't suppose to wear feathers on their heads and only said in prayers. I don't know though, even other tribes are expanding their talents and imaginations as far as regalia is concerned. Nothing is official as far as designs and colors, so they have expanded with style. I'm still proud of my Dine' background and I think we look beautiful in our traditional clothing, especially the rug dresses...........beautiful.
                              Fall down 7 times, get up 8. MY FAMOUS WORDS.

                              Comment

                              Join the online community forum celebrating Native American Culture, Pow Wows, tribes, music, art, and history.

                              Related Topics

                              Collapse

                              • luvstraightdancrs
                                Finally, someone said it!
                                by luvstraightdancrs
                                Here is an email that I received yesterday, I think it is dead on! Just wondering how many of you feel the same way.


                                "Nostalgia: Indian Style



                                Joseph Shunkamolah 4/18/2008



                                I was wondering the other day why all...
                                04-26-2008, 08:55 AM
                              • Blackbear
                                HAZEL'S UPDATES April 23, 2007
                                by Blackbear
                                HAZEL'S UPDATES April 23, 2007

                                --------------------------------------------------------------------------------

                                April 23, 2007

                                I've held off writing this update because for one, I didn't know whether I should or not. My concern was putting out there what...
                                04-25-2007, 05:24 AM
                              • Grits & Beans
                                upside down canadian flag at manito ahbee grand entry
                                by Grits & Beans


                                A humble statement on the events that transpired at Manito Ahbe.

                                [Normally I don’t write or talk about myself as far as what I do or have done in the past. Given the circumstances, I was encouraged by Last Real Indians, along with friends, to highlight a perspectives...
                                08-21-2013, 01:53 PM
                              • marichriaddi
                                some nutty thoughts I had on the bean
                                by marichriaddi
                                A better future
                                I keep reading letters to the editor at the newspaper I work at from people talking about what the tribes needs to do to help people. I agree on some level about what they say, but at the same time, I can’t help but to think that the tribe building some treatment facility...
                                10-24-2007, 11:51 AM
                              • Coyot_In_The_House
                                Did You Ever....
                                by Coyot_In_The_House
                                Have the oppurtunity to grow up with some rather cool people and continue on with that experience thru the years but, but.....There was always a small percentage who were just miserable? You know that contingent of people that no matter what anyone did.......were just never satisfied? Seems this way...
                                01-18-2008, 11:33 AM

                              Trending

                              Collapse

                              Sidebar Ad

                              Collapse
                              Working...
                              X